I think if this happened in canon it would have made Quinn almost too villainous. At least with the hot-tub story, partial blame can be assigned to Finn for his naivete, so Quinn's bumpy redemption arc is a little easier for viewers to believe.

The feedback polls are really interesting to me for that sort of reason. I'm half-tempted to meta more about it, given the recent meta-discussions about commenting etiquette and everything, but I don't know yet what I'd be thinking. TOO MUCH TO READ.